Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Explaining Jeremy Lin's Early, Surprising Success

More Variety Necessary in Starting Goalie Assignments

(I was already writing this before Emery was scratched for tonight's game in Edmonton, but now it's even timelier, I suppose).

There are two stereotypes that have stuck with the Flyers for decades: constant goonery and constant goalie controversies.  And since there has been little goonery to speak of recently, let's turn our attention to the latter of the two phenomena. 

There has been a decided lack of balance in the starting goaltending assignments throughout this entire season.  A quick refresher of the twists and turns that have already taken place this season for the Flyers:

  1. Ray Emery got 18 of the first 20 decisions of the season. 
  2. That opening Emery era was followed shortly thereafter by a Boucher era, in which Boucher took 13 of the next 15 decisions. 
  3. On the back of an injury to Emery and some poor play by the team, the Boucher era was followed by 10 of the next 11 decisions going to newcomer Michael Leighton.
  4. With Emery healthy again, Leighton was put on the shelf after a 4-0 loss to Toronto.  Emery has now gotten 8 of the last 8 decisions.

There's no sign from on high that this fourth phase of Flyer goaltending that sees Emery firmly in control is going to end any time soon.  But is that wise?

Before Michael Leighton was relegated to door opener, he compiled an incredible 8-1-1 record, with a 92.0% save percentage and a 2.39 GAA.  But he hasn't been given a single chance to play since his first regulation loss, until tonight's game in Edmonton for which Emery is not even in the lineup.

Ray Emery has been pretty good since taking over.  He's gone 5-3-0, with a 90.2% save percentage and a 2.12 GAA.  And he's gotten two shutouts, including in his most recent game.  There's been some iffy rebound control, but the numbers have been incredibly solid.  But by no means is Emery so hot that some rest would be detrimental to the teams chances, especially with a backup goaltender on the bench who has won eight of his ten decisions.

Further to the point, the first era of nearly non-stop Emery starts was only halted because of injury.  The injury occurred under Stevens' watch, but hopefully Laviolette looked back far enough to know that overworking a goaltender like that can't be good in the long run, especially with only 28 games left in the regular season.

My position on this is pretty simple: Leighton should be seeing a lot more ice time than none, which is what he's been getting lately. 

Agree? Vote in the poll below, and articulate any and all other feelings on the matter in the comments...

Poll
Do you think there needs to be more sharing of the Flyers' starting goaltending duties?
Yes
115 votes
No
43 votes

158 votes | Poll has closed

Comment 14 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

I think it’s pretty simple actually. If starting Leighton means the Flyers win, then start Leighton. If starting Emery means the Flyers win, then start Emery. Hello Mr. Stanley Cup.

by edbro on Feb 3, 2010 5:05 PM EST reply actions  

So basically win and your in.

Im not sure about that. I think Emery is a good enough goalie to win a cup. We should definately be giving him more days off, but I think that hes the one that should be getting the bulk of the starts. Maybe like 70-30 Emery.

by philiafan14364 on Feb 3, 2010 5:19 PM EST up reply actions  

Play Emery against the good teams to get him in playoff (PLAYOFFS!!!?) shape, and give him a rest when the Flyer’s opponent is a bit more shitty, a la Edmonton. Seems like a pretty simple formula for success.

by halx on Feb 3, 2010 5:29 PM EST reply actions  

maybe a little more shuffling is necessary, but the reality is if this team is going anywhere its going to be with Ray Emery between the pipes. now before someone slams me with some ridiculous advanced and detailed statistical data that shows Emery actually sucks, im saying that more based on gut feeling than anything else. Emery has taken his team deep in the playoffs before, he has “#1 goaltender talent”, the other two are backups who played well during a stretch when the team was so awful they had no choice but to stand on their heads.

I dont disagree that we need to shuffle the goaltenders more, but not too much more. every year we have this revolving door of goaltenders where it is a big mystery as to who will be the guy in the playoffs. that messes with the heads of the goaltender and the guys in front of him.

by njh3293 on Feb 3, 2010 5:45 PM EST reply actions  

Even if someone slammed you with sabermetric data that says Emery sucked, Id still be inclined to side with you. I just dont think that peripheral stats are that relevant in hockey.

by philiafan14364 on Feb 3, 2010 5:58 PM EST up reply actions  

Believe it or not, my feeling on Emery is exactly the opposite. His numbers this year are good, but I just don’t like how he looks recently. Even against Calgary, he didn’t look fantastic.

Broad Street Hockey - Makin' it look mean since 1967.

by Geoff Detweiler on Feb 3, 2010 6:26 PM EST up reply actions  

Emery is going to have two weeks off. Hopefully he’s ready for the resumption of the season in March.

Also Elliotte Friedman from HNIC – who is one of my favorite hockey reporters out there – still is saying to not underestimate the Flyers for Kovalchuk. Not saying anything other than the Flyers name is apparently still out there.

by Michael4L on Feb 3, 2010 6:02 PM EST reply actions  

Yeah, I’ve read a lot of that today. Flyers still involved on him though. It hurts my brain.

Broad Street Hockey - SB Nation's Philadelphia Flyers Blog. Makin' it look mean since 1967.

by Travis Hughes on Feb 3, 2010 6:04 PM EST up reply actions  

Simply put, I don’t think we’re good enough this year to justify a rental.

The Daily Forehand -- SB Nation's Tennis Destination.
Broad Street Hockey.

by Ben Rothenberg on Feb 3, 2010 6:15 PM EST up reply actions  

the rental concept may work in our favor if we make the right move. Kovalchuk leaving in free agency will give us the cap room that we havnt had in 3 years to fully adress our needs.

one of the ESPN.com guys (Hradek, Lebrun, dont remember which) wrote a piece a few weeks ago about how in the modern NHL youve really got to make every year a go for it year. Look at the Carolina Hurricanes. the difference between a conference finals appearance and the NHL cellar is often one or two players not playing up to their level and an injury or two. Add the ever fluctuating cap into the mix and you really cant plan too far ahead. Thats not to say you should always mortgage the future for obvious reasons, but when you have a shot to go for a super star who can help you win the cup, you cant pass up on it for reasons like free agency.

by njh3293 on Feb 3, 2010 6:36 PM EST up reply actions  

One more thing. Here’s his page over on CBC’s website. Always a good read for anyone who might not know of him or want to bookmark more hockey talk.

http://www.cbc.ca/sports/blogs/2010/02/salary_cap_looms_over_trade_ta.html

by Michael4L on Feb 3, 2010 6:04 PM EST reply actions  

Panaccio saying the Leighton is starting tonight because Emery has a sore groin.

by Mitchell Green on Feb 3, 2010 7:17 PM EST reply actions  

No goalie should be playing every game. The highest ATOI for any player right now is 27:17 for Joni Pitkanen. A goalie playing every game has an ATOI of 60:00. You don’t wear your goalie down by playing him every game. Maybe you just use the backup in back-to-backs, where you’d have Emery and Leighton/Boucher split the games, but Razor (or Leighton, or Boosh) simply can’t play every game without fatigue becoming an issue.

"When you make your final stand
I'll be right there
I'll never leave
And all I ask of you is
Believe"

by The Dark on Feb 3, 2010 8:42 PM EST reply actions  

well apparently they didn’t get the message because as flysfrk05 noted Emery’s sore groin is why Leighton got the nod …not good for someone whose just had surgery for a Sportsman Hernia.

by j reed on Feb 4, 2010 3:08 AM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

All the Philadelphia Flyers news and commentary that's fit to print.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Claude_doop_small
Max Talbot: Quietly Defying Your Expectations

Recent FanPosts

Small
Should the Flyers consider buying out Bryzgalov contract?
Nfs_pic_small
Bachelor Party in Philly
Small
Stop whining about shoot outs.
640_flypen_thrillainphila_small
PLAYING WITH CAPGEEK ROSTERS
Flyers_small
Shootouts
Small
What is the Flyers Defensive Philosophy?
Clarke-tee_small
Roller Pick-Up Game Feb 25?
Assholeheart_small
"Be Excellent to Each Other!" (in Keanu Reeves voice)
Claude_doop_small
Goalies and Back-to-Backs
Clarke-tee_small
BSH OPEN ICE 3/17

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

Screen_shot_2012-01-09_at_12 Travis Hughes

Associate Editors

67865_878600804923_14200876_46395212_2220_n_small Geoff Detweiler

Headshot2_film_grain_small Ben Rothenberg

Soccer_face_small Eric T.

Contributors

163830_478172269164_824914164_5517468_4313370_n_small ToddtheFox

Clarke-tee_small KreiderDesigns

D150_small Teemu H