Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Watch Out For Cowboys UDFA Tim Benford

Which Goalie Will It Be?


As of right now the Flyers' goaltending situation does not look very good. We have Michael Leighton, the 29 year-old journey man, and Brian Boucher, who had been a back-up his whole career. We have all heard rumors about possible goalies joining the Flyers, but lets take a look at some of the possibilities.

Star-divide

Marty Turco

This could be a very big steal for the Flyers. If Philadelphia could some how ink Turco to  around a 2 million dollar deal for no more than 2 season, we're good to go. He is still a starting goaltender and has a lot left in the tank. Turco had a rough end to his stint with the Stars, but also had an awful defense in front of him. Should Turco join the Flyers, he would have a lot less preasure put upon him with the likes of Chris Pronger and Kimmo Timonen helping him out in the net.

Jose Theodore

This is a name that has been linked more than once to the Flyers. I would be uncomfortable with Theo. Even though he had a strong season with the Capitals, I believe taht Theodore will be a bust. Theo would not to teribbly in Philly, but would be a waste of money. There is no substantial upgrade by going from Leighton to Turco.

Mike Smith

Another name that has been linked to the Flyers. There have been rumors about Simon Gagne going to the Lightning with Smith coming back the other way. Smith again would be no substantial upgrade from Leighton. He's young and has not proven himself to be a number one guy in the N.H.L. Smith is a solid back-up and I believe in time will become good, but needs to be eased in alongside a proven starter.

Jonathan Quick

Quick would be a phenomal pick-up for the Flyers. He's young, fast and strong. He proved he was a capable starter this year with his strong season and making the U.S.A. national team. He will become an elite goalie as his career goes on would be a steal should the Flyers be able to land him.

Jonathan Bernier

Bernier is the second half of the Kings' young goaltending tandom. Bernier is a lot like Quick. Young, talented and unlimited potential. The Kings' have a lugxury that most teams would kill for: the choice between two young franchise goaltenders. The Canadiens are the only team that has had this situation in recent years with having to chose between Jaroslav Halak and Carey Price. Bernier would also be a steal much like Quick would.

So all of these goaltenders may end up in Philly come the fall. I doubt that Bernier and Quick will end up in Philly. I think that the Flyers believe they may have a future goaie in either Sergei Bobrovsky or Nicola Riopel. I think that both Smith and Theodore would be no substantial upgrade, therefore I doubt the Flyers would waste the cap space. So that leaves Turco, who I believe will end up in the orange and black. I believe that Holmgren will only make room for a goalie that will give them a true chance at winning the cup and Turco would give them a chance.

So what is your opinion?

Poll
So Who Do You Think/Want The Flyers Will Sign?
Marty Turco
44 votes
Jose Theodore
6 votes
Mike Smith
1 votes
Jonathan Quick
15 votes
Jonathan Bernier
17 votes

83 votes | Poll has closed

This item was written by a member of this community and is not necessarily endorsed by Broad Street Hockey.

Comment 15 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

None of the Above.

I think Holmgren has gone all-in on upgrading the D and he’s going to take his chance with Leighton and Boucher in net.

by Flyer Fan on Jul 18, 2010 12:34 AM EDT reply actions  

I agree, but it will most likely be Leighton/Backlund. If Homer hadn’t re-signed Backlund, then I think it would have Leighton/Boucher.

#1 Flyers fan in England (originally from Southeastern PA)

by Orange and Black Forever on Jul 18, 2010 9:47 AM EDT up reply actions  

Agree

Backing Backlund for 2010-2011

by ToddtheFox on Jul 18, 2010 6:11 PM EDT up reply actions  

And at this point who is to say that Backlund doesn’t come into camp and outplay Leighton AND Boosh?

by Fezzlekway on Jul 19, 2010 11:20 AM EDT up reply actions  

And create a three-way goalie controversy? That never happens in Philadelphia!

This would actually please me. Nothing at all against Leights and Boosh, I just think it’d be fun to see him step up and say “watch and learn, son.”

Lightning strikes once, Hextall strikes twice!

by hintzy64 on Jul 19, 2010 12:21 PM EDT up reply actions  

i’m not sold on the idea that homer is going to take his chances on Leights and Boosh. There have been way too many goalie related rumors for it sound like Homer is content. I think our first choice is Quick but it’s doubtful that we can pry him loose from LA, same for Bernier and Bernier is unproven at nhl level. I just don’t think LA will trade one of those two (yet but they will down the line) unless they are wowed by trade (gagne by himself is not going to do it). My guess is that after trading gagne they sign Turco. I think Boosh is likely headed out of town or one way or another.

by historywillbemade on Jul 18, 2010 9:50 AM EDT reply actions  

Gagne will go a goalie will be here and I am pretty sure it will between Turco and Theodore. They are practically the same age and pretty much the same size. Turco handles the puck extremely well. I rather have Turco.

by chrislanci on Jul 18, 2010 4:50 PM EDT up reply actions  

me too. Turco has better career stats as well

by historywillbemade on Jul 18, 2010 8:08 PM EDT up reply actions  

Goalies 'R' Us...

I think the Flyers BIGGEST issue was, as the playoffs showed, DEFENSE…I don’t care if you are 36 or 26, you cannot play 29-30 minutes a night without wearing down. Only being able to CONFIDENTLY roll four defensemen in the playoffs killed us. I think Leights would have been fine had Pronger,Timonen,Coburn, & Carle not been completely burned out…Homer has addressed this situation admirably, on paper the Flyers may now have the deepest/most experienced Starting Six in the League (with the additions of Meszaros and O’Donnell to be our #5 & #6), and bringing in O’Donnell is also good in that he and Pronger helped mature Anaheim’s young defensemen a couple of seasons ago and with Kimmo’s help I believe they will do the same here…

All that being said, there are goaltending issues that have not, but COULD have been addressed…

Re-signing Leights for 2 years @ 1.55M…Good Signing…
Other than that?
Not so good…

Tried low-balling Nabby, no go…
Tried low-balling Turco, no go…yet…

Could have signed Dan Ellis, who I think would have been a perfect compliment to Leights giving us a 1a & 1b tandem (Unfortunately Boosh is the odd man out). Ellis signed for a measly $1.5M/year for 2 years with Tampa…for that price Jody Shelley should be washing dishes at Denny’s and Ellis should be pulling on an Orange Sweater…

Hell, we could have brought Biron back to Philly to back up Leights. Only $895k/Year for 2 years. Smaller Cap Hit than Boosh and would have been an upgrade…

That is all moot now…

So…

Theodore? Maybe like 3-4 years ago I would have jumped to sign him, no so much now.

Turco, probably the Flyers best bet (barring a trade that nets us a goalie (no pun intended))…I think Marty is probably starting to realize that this year for Goalies, it is a BUYER’S, NOT a Seller’s market…Once Homer dishes off a fan favorite to clear the Cap Space, he is most likely the target and by that time will most likely have lowered his contract demands.

Mike Smith, I would rather have Dan Ellis (see above)

Quick & Bernier, I don’t think you are prying either of these guys away from the Kings without giving up something significant.

Johan Backlund: An interesting situation, just signed a 2 year deal, and may just come into camp and outplay Leights AND Boosh (wouldn’t THAT be nice…here’s hopin’)

Sergei Bobrovsky: Well I sure HOPE this guy is the Goalie of the future considering we have $5.25M committed to him over the next 3 years…

And for now? We wait…

Cheers,

Fezzy
http://fezzysworld.blogspot.com

by Fezzlekway on Jul 19, 2010 12:21 PM EDT reply actions  

does the defense let up soft goals? No I’m pretty sure that was Leighton. Goaltending lost us the finals. there were tons of soft goals let up by leights and boosh.

by historywillbemade on Jul 19, 2010 1:15 PM EDT up reply actions  

While I agree, here were some ‘soft’ goals…Even the best goalies let up soft goals. Yes, even the Brodeur’s and the Roy’s have let in their share of soft goals. And I do understand that it’s the time of year you need your goalie to make the easy save. However, how many of them were preventable had Lavvy been able to roll 3 defense pairs instead of continuing to roll Pronger,Timmo,Carle,Coburn out there when they were clearly not firing on all cylinders…

Now, HONESTLY…cut Pronger/Timmonen/Carle & Coburn’s playoff minutes back by 3.5-5 minutes a game each. Now your Top 4 actually get a minute to rest between shifts, they’re not still panting from the last shift. Think those weak chances still become soft goals? I, for one, do not…

Niemi wasn’t that great, but the defense in front of him narrowed the chances. When the Flyers got through Keith/Sopel/Seabrook/Hjalmarsson/Campbell, they kinda made Niemi look…ordinary…

Good Goaltending and a Solid Starting Six is enough to get you a cup (of course it would be easier with steller goaltending, but when did we last have that in the Orange & Black?)

Cheers,

Fezzy
http://fezzysworld.blogspot.com

by Fezzlekway on Jul 19, 2010 2:00 PM EDT up reply actions   1 recs

but we don’t even have good goaltending we have below average goaltending. we probably have 2nd worst starting tandem in the league. Yes even the great goalies let up soft goals but Leighton let up 2-3 soft goals per game in the finals and only ever looked good b/c we have great top 4 and were facing low scoring teams (nj, montreal, boston)

by historywillbemade on Jul 19, 2010 10:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

Did those “tired” defensemen make mistakes that led to goals? Maybe in Game 5, but the whole team played like absolute shit. While I agree that the top-4 played too many minutes in the playoffs, I didn’t see any goals resulting from tired players. I saw plenty of goals resulting from good shots, bad shifts, and bad goaltending, but none because our defensemen were burnt out.

That’s where you lose me.

Man-crushin' on Boucher since 1999
Broad Street Hockey - Makin' it look mean since 1967.

by Geoff Detweiler on Jul 20, 2010 5:00 PM EDT up reply actions  

matt walker

he’ll be our goalie, since we have like 8 defensivemen now, lol…… just kidding. i’m sure we’ll keep leighton and boosh since we have the best and most expensive and most expensive defense

...yay

by naf snihplod on Jul 20, 2010 8:52 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

All the Philadelphia Flyers news and commentary that's fit to print.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Flyers-orange-crush_small
NHL Draft 2012: Options on defense in the first round
Copy_of_137494800_slide_small
The 2011-12 Philadelphia Flyers season in GIFs

Recent FanPosts

Patal_small
Andrew Johnston Scouting Report
Small
What being a Hockey fan means to me.
Small
Could Parise and Weber be in Flyers' future?
Mick_jagr_2_small
SB Nation app
Small
Hockey Stick Help
37938_10150235117290484_539355483_13709206_6888144_n_small
Ilya Bryzgalov has chance to take shot at Flyers fans, does
Small
Can the Flyers win the Cup with Bryz?
Carcillo_small
Flyers in the Off-Season

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

Screen_shot_2012-01-09_at_12 Travis Hughes

Associate Editors

67865_878600804923_14200876_46395212_2220_n_small Geoff Detweiler

Headshot2_film_grain_small Ben Rothenberg

Soccer_face_small Eric T.

Contributors

163830_478172269164_824914164_5517468_4313370_n_small ToddtheFox

Clarke-tee_small KreiderDesigns

D150_small Teemu H