Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Most Dangerous Division in Sports

Why Concussion Epidemic May be Good for the Game

I wrote this over on a blog I write for and thought I'd share it with you guys. Enjoy.

Star-divide

In the past two months, concussions have been running rampant in NHL. While part of that may be general recklessness that happens in the game of hockey, especially at the highest level of hockey in the world, the other part may be the fact that we are getting better at recognizing concussion-like symptoms. While it may be too late for some guys to salvage their careers, and that could be for any number of circumstances that may include age or prior concussions, this rash of concussions may actually benefit the game. That may sound twisted, but I implore you to keep reading.

During this month alone, the Flyers have lost three players to concussions. Brayden Schenn was the key piece of the deal that sent former Flyers captain Mike Richards to the Los Angeles Kings. He's played in six games this year due to starting the year with the team's AHL affiliate, the Adirondack Phantoms, for rehabilitation of a shoulder injury and cap constraints. When he was finally called up, he took a slapshot from PK Subban of the Montreal Canadiens off of his foot, and as we were to find out later, the shot broke his foot. He returned that to face a new issue, and that is this "mild" concussion. Hopefully, this is just "one of those years" for the 20-year-old Schenn and he can come back and finish the year with the Flyers strongly. Current Flyer captain Chris Pronger has also fallen as a victim of post-concussion-syndrome. We just found out yesterday that he will be placed on LTIR (long-term injured reserve) for the remainder of the regular season and playoffs (if the Flyers do make it). This will be a huge loss for the Flyers on the blue line as Pronger is one of the best in the game, no matter if you hate him or love him. Many have called for the Flyers to go out and acquire either Shea Weber or Ryan Suter from the Nashville Predators, but currently playing are rookies Kevin Marshall and Marc-Andre Bourdon. Both have been rather pleasant surprises because no one expected them to be NHL ready at the end of training camp. Finally, emerging superstar Claude Giroux was recently diagnosed with a concussion and is out "indefinitely". It is believed he sustained his concussion after taking an accidental knee to the head from teammate Wayne Simmonds. Giroux was leading the NHL in points with 39 in 28 games, a three point lead on second place Phil Kessel of the Toronto Maple Leafs. Giroux and 39 year-old Jaromir Jagr were looking to be one of the most dominant duos in the NHL this season and have turned linemate Scott Hartnell's season around.

Around the league, many other star players were going down with head injuries as well. Leading goal scorer Milan Michalek, of the Ottawa Senators, Jeff Skinner, of the Carolina Hurricanes, and NHL megastar Sidney Crosby are the three big players effected. Crosby had played only 8 games after coming back from a 10 month absence from the game due to a concussion sustained during a collision with David Steckel during last year's Winter Classic and then a vicious hit from Tampa Bay defender Victor Hedman in successive games. Skinner was last year's Calder Trophy winner, besting Islander, Michael Grabner, and San Jose Shark, Logan Couture. He was one of the only shining stars for the Carolina Hurricanes, as their season has gotten of to a horrendous beginning that saw former coach, Paul Maurice, get fired. Captain Eric Staal has not been living up to expectations and stalwart goaltender, Cam Ward, has looked relatively average up to this point. Michalek has been a key part of the turnaround for the Senators. After a 7-2 trouncing on home ice handed to them by the Flyers, the Senators' season has been trending upwards. Michalek led the league in goals with 19 and was a frontrunner in All-Star voting.

For players like Giroux and Skinner, this early diagnosis may help them to have better careers than if they were to play a few years back, when concussions were not taken as seriously as they are today. They will come back eventually and enjoy a long and fruitful career, hopefully being less susceptible to concussions then they would be if the signs hadn't been spotted almost immediately. Crosby's status is still a little bit up in the air since he played such a short time before succumbing to symptoms after a collision with teammate, Chris Kunitz. Having those players back as soon as possible can only be good for the game of hockey itself. Three of it's top players, or soon to be, are sidelined. For players like the 37 year-old Pronger, the early diagnosis and emphasis on better treatment may help him lead a better life, less effected by his symptoms, outside of the game.

Concussions suck, I know that first hand. However, with the treatment at hand and the fact that teams are getting so good at recognizing symptoms, along with advancements in safety equipment, can mean good things for the game.

This item was written by a member of this community and is not necessarily endorsed by Broad Street Hockey.

Comment 5 comments  |  Add comment  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Interesting perspective. But I think that with concussions, the bad will always drown out the good.

Awaiting the return of the G-stache

by Philly37 on Dec 16, 2011 10:07 PM EST reply actions  

I’m with you that it’s good for the health of our current players that the teams are learning to address the issues and provide better care. Anything that gets them proper treatment to prevent long-term effects is a very good thing.

I can’t concede on it being good for the game, though. Is the stigma of a concussion epidemic going to be a setback for the league from a marketing and PR standpoint? How many more parents are going to stop their kids from playing hockey because it’s become omnipresent? Can we expect this level of care to filter all the way down to younger kids who start are playing organized hockey? I’m not sure how the ripple effects of this will play out at this point.

Warning: Arguing the NHL CBA with me could be hazardous to your mental health. Proceed at your own risk.

by DragonGirl0583 on Dec 16, 2011 10:40 PM EST reply actions  

I never thought about the points you brought up in your second paragraph. I meant in the NHL, specifically, but all of those are really valid points that may need to be addressed. I just don’t know by who or what.

OMB!
Flyers writer at hockeytracker.net
Follow me @HTJohnMoritz (BSH is doing it, why aren't you)

by FlyerFan139 on Dec 16, 2011 10:51 PM EST up reply actions  

Your headline is a bit misguided. Yes, detecting and properly treating concussions is a very good thing, but the concussions themselves are not, for the reasons stated above.

It’s interesting looking back at some things in my life now in light of all this. I’ve had 6 of these things, albeit none of them were severe- only one had a loss of consciousness and I remember “waking up” afterward. Most were minor and went about my business thinking nothing of it. There is one, though, that has me wondering…

My freshmen year, I went up against a much bigger guy in something similar to the joust from American Gladiators. Well, as soon as the whistle blew, the guy smashed up right on the head with his stick and I remember seeing a big pink star and just sorta standing there until he put a body blow on me and sent me flying off the pedestal. Thought nothing of it. I went back to school the next week, and remember being in a strange fog- writing letters upside-down and getting migraines every other week or so for a solid 3-4 months. Then I started to train for the track team the next fall, but had to quit because whenever I ran I’d get auras in my vision and started to get wicked headaches. Enough was enough and I had to stop, two weeks into training . I never put those three things together until this week.

That was 14 years ago. Since then, I’ve completed 11 marathons, so running distances is no longer a problem. But, I get frequent headaches to this day, and am sensitive to bright light. Thankfully, college only lasted 4 years, so I couldn’t get more of them on the frisbee fields…

Babe, Bucky, Buckner, Boone, BALTIMORE!!!

by goldomatic on Dec 16, 2011 11:01 PM EST reply actions   1 recs

Yes, it may seem a bit misguided, huh? I merely meant that the fact that teams are figuring out when guys have concussions is a good thing. Not to sound like a dick, but I never said concussions were a good thing, but mainly the fact that the acknowledgement of these injuries is good and that we’re taking the right steps in prevention. Concussions have always been around, but no one knew about it. Now we do and it could help countless players, starting with the five I mentioned here.

OMB!
Flyers writer at hockeytracker.net
Follow me @HTJohnMoritz (BSH is doing it, why aren't you)

by FlyerFan139 on Dec 17, 2011 12:28 AM EST up reply actions  


User Tools

All the Philadelphia Flyers news and commentary that's fit to print.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Flyers-orange-crush_small
NHL Draft 2012: Options on defense in the first round

Recent FanPosts

Patal_small
Andrew Johnston Scouting Report: A first-hand look at the Flyers newest prospect
Small
What being a Hockey fan means to me.
Small
Could Parise and Weber be in Flyers' future?
Mick_jagr_2_small
SB Nation app
Small
Hockey Stick Help
Copy_of_137494800_slide_small
The 2011-12 Philadelphia Flyers season in GIFs
37938_10150235117290484_539355483_13709206_6888144_n_small
Ilya Bryzgalov has chance to take shot at Flyers fans, does
Small
Can the Flyers win the Cup with Bryz?
Carcillo_small
Flyers in the Off-Season

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managing Editor

Screen_shot_2012-01-09_at_12 Travis Hughes

Associate Editors

67865_878600804923_14200876_46395212_2220_n_small Geoff Detweiler

Headshot2_film_grain_small Ben Rothenberg

Soccer_face_small Eric T.

Contributors

163830_478172269164_824914164_5517468_4313370_n_small ToddtheFox

Clarke-tee_small KreiderDesigns

D150_small Teemu H