The Philadelphia Flyers announced that they have sent defenseman Hunter McDonald back down to the AHL’s Lehigh Valley Phantoms on Saturday afternoon in a somewhat confusing roster move.
It was a numbers game to remain on the Flyers roster and McDonald was the player that was then sacrificed and removed from the roster so that injured players can then come back for Sunday’s game against the Utah Mammoth. It’s just a disheartening decision that it was the 24-year-old defenseman that was chosen.
McDonald has been with the team since he was recalled on Oct. 18 after blueliner Cam York went down with an injury and they needed another body. He has been on the edge of the NHL as a hyped-up and physically mature (and older) defenseman prospect who the front office seems to really like. There have been ups and downs ever since he left Northeastern University and turned pro over two years ago, but McDonald has now found a fairly solid footing as someone who could at least contribute on the big stage.
It was a risk bringing him up but in a sink-or-swim kind of move, McDonald proved that he could very well serve on the bottom pairing of an NHL roster. When they needed someone to fill in for Nick Seeler, who took York’s spot on the second pairing during his absence, he was there and did his job. In the five appearances he made, McDonald earned zero points but delivered 21 hits and dropped the gloves a couple times. He even drew some very timely penalties that gave the Flyers some in-game advantages.
He held his head high above water — McDonald wasn’t some sort of difference-maker in the way his former Phantoms teammate Oliver Bonk has been, but he’s provided a level of physicality that has been lacking on the Flyers during this losing streak.
Unfortunately, a roster move had to be made.
Flyers choose to not rattle the roster by sending McDonald down
Travis Konecny and Owen Tippett are making their way back from injury. Both of the top wingers were on the Injured Reserve list, which makes them not count against the 23-man roster limit. But with at least one of them returning — Tippett is basically guaranteed to return on Sunday while Konecny is possible — a move had to be made.
So, instead of shaking things up, the Flyers decided to go the easy route. Instead of thinking that any of the depth veterans who have been playing poorly doesn’t deserve their spot, they then sent down the defenseman that just got there and is fighting for his NHL life.
The options were there in front of them, and it even involved someone that they aren’t even playing.
David Jiricek has been a healthy scratch for four consecutives games, while McDonald has taken his spot on the Flyers blue line. Head coach Rick Tocchet has, on multiple occasions, chosen to play the physical McDonald over Jiricek, who is talented but is essentially guaranteed to make several mistakes that could lead to goals. The coach has made his preference clear.
But because Jiricek will require waivers, while McDonald does not, the choice must have felt pretty easy for the front office to make. They don’t want to lose the former sixth-overall pick, who they traded winger Bobby Brink for last season, off to some other team for nothing in return. So instead, they send down McDonald.
Jiricek’s time with the Flyers might not last beyond this season, but sure, don’t lose that asset. There were other choices that could’ve been made.
Simon Benoit is not doing anything at all and it might be even more telling that McDonald, who plays a very similar game to the 28-year-old defender, is getting picked over him when it comes to who is in the lineup lately. Benoit has been a disaster ever since he was acquired from the Toronto Maple Leafs as a side piece in the Joseph Woll trade. He hasn’t shown that he can think the game fast enough in his own zone to defend well and since the Flyers are doing a whole lot of defending, they need someone stable back there. McDonald might be averaging just 12:37 time-on-ice this season, but he hasn’t had any big gaffs, and he’s been the team’s most physical player when they have needed someone to step up. McDonald has two more hits than Benoit has had this season in just half the amount of games.
Sending Benoit down through waivers could’ve been something so easy to do and no one would pick him up anyways. The pending unrestricted free agent doesn’t have a future in Philadelphia, so why not choose McDonald over him? The 24-year-old might have a long run as a bottom-pairing guy here while Benoit goes and plays for some other organization several months from now.
And this isn’t going to be the end of this preference of veterans over players who could be here for a while.
More moves will come that prefer veterans over the prospects
By sending McDonald down the Flyers are at 22 healthy players on their roster with Tippett, Konecny, and Rasmus Ristolainen on IR. Reassigning the 24-year-old only lets one of them come back, but since it certainly looks like both Tippett and Konecny could be making their return on Sunday against Utah, they will need to do another move.
According to Bill Meltzer, if those wingers come back then it will be 22-year-old Cole Knuble as the other sacrifice the Flyers make.
It would be maybe an even more undeserving demotion. Knuble has been exactly what he has been sold as — a high-energy bottom-six forward who might just have enough scoring potential to play higher up in the lineup if a little jolt is needed.
And instead of the veterans like Michael Bunting, who wasn’t even on this team a month ago, getting sent down to the AHL, it will be Knuble who goes back down to the Phantoms because it is the easy move and it doesn’t mean any risk of losing a player or ruffling the feathers of a veteran. It’s just easy to send the kids down because then no one will really make a fuss, right?
For a team that is looking for some energy and compete and jam, potentially sending down both McDonald and Knuble instead of some slow veterans who have not made any impact whatsoever, is certainly a confusing move. These two young players aren’t supposed to be major players or anything, but guys who have a ceiling as real solid depth players in the NHL — and they have shown to already be exactly that so far this season.

